Asia's Top Young Universities: NTU vs HKUST

In the new edition of the QS Top 50 Under 50, released this week, Singapore’s Nanyang Technological University (NTU) was once again ranked as the the world’s top university under 50 years old, closely followed by the Hong Kong University of Science and Technology (HKUST).

In general, dynamic young Asian universities dominate the top tier of the QS Top 50 Under 50, which celebrates the world’s leading institutions under 50 years old. NTU and HKUST are joined in the top five by two more Asian universities: South Korea’s KAIST at third, and the City University of Hong Kong at fifth.

While Nanyang Technological University has now led the Top 50 Under 50 for five consecutive years, HKUST has previously claimed the top spot, and the two remain closely matched.

Here’s a closer look at how these two ambitious Asian universities compare…

 *Based on the broad subject areas of the QS World University Rankings by Subject 2018.

QS World University Rankings® 2019

Nanyang Technological University (NTU) continues to outrank Hong Kong University of Science and Technology (HKUST) in the QS World University Rankings® and the QS Top 50 Under 50, with both top Asian universities down slightly on last year.

When taking a closer look, both institutions perform well in the indicators used to compile the rankings, with each university ranked in the top 300 for each one. NTU achieves higher scores for its reputations among academics and graduate employers, gaining a wider lead on the employer reputation indicator.

For research impact, HKUST is the leader of the two, with NTU ranked 87^th. This is assessed by counting the number of research citations published per faculty member at the university. However, when assessing the ratio of academic staff members to students, NTU has a clear lead – ranked more than 160 places ahead of HKUST at 79^th.

Finally, looking at the level of international diversity on each campus, both young universities get high scores, with HKUST in the lead both for its percentage of international faculty members and international students – however, NTU still features in the global top 150 for both indicators.

Subject strengths

If you’re still trying to decide between NTU and HKUST, a look at the QS World University Rankings by Subject can help narrow down each university’s individual subject strengths. NTU is the leader for four out of the five broad subject areas included in the rankings, ranking only five places behind HKUST for social sciences & management, at 29^th to HKUST’s 24^th.

The table below lets you see how NTU and HKUST directly compare for each discipline.

Location

Both these rival Asian universities are in huge, bustling cities, both of which are considered expensive to live in but offer great economic prosperity and job opportunities. NTU is found in the West Region of Singapore, adjacent to the town of Jurong West, and boasts the largest university campus in the city at 490 acres. HKUST meanwhile is set in the attractive Clear Water Bay area on a 150-acre campus less than 30 minutes’ drive from central Hong Kong (SAR).

Looking at the QS Best Student Cities 2018, Hong Kong has a slight lead, ranked 12^th while Singapore is ranked 15^th. When you consider the indicators used to compile the rankings, Singapore beats Hong Kong for desirability and employer activity, whereas Hong Kong achieves a much higher score for affordability (and a slightly stronger score for ‘student view’).

Rent in Hong Kong is often considered extortionate but traveling and eating out can be done at a low cost. Singapore was also ranked as the world’s most expensive city in The Economist's Worldwide Cost of Living Survey 2018. This might sound alarming, but if you take tuition fees into account, both Singapore and Hong Kong are still more affordable than other popular study destinations. Both are also highly multicultural, with Hong Kong branded as "Asia's World City", so you should adapt easily to living here no matter where you’re from originally.

Student community

NTU has around 31,800 students, of which 8,074 are postgraduates, while HKUST is much smaller, with less than half the number of students NTU has at approximately 14,807 students (roughly two-thirds of whom are undergraduates). There’s no data for the number of international students at NTU, but at HKUST there were 5,060 as of September 2017, which is 34 percent of the total number, and the university also receives a stronger score than NTU for its percentage of international students.

Tuition fees

Tuition fees at both NTU and HKUST vary depending on your study level, subject and other factors – at NTU, fees are affected by whether students are in receipt of the MOE Tuition Grant. These grants, offered by the Ministry of Education, can help both domestic and international students cover a significant amount of their tuition costs, in exchange for agreeing to work for a Singaporean company for at least three years after graduating (or five or six years for medicine and dentistry graduates). The table below gives you an idea of how the most recent figures for tuition fees at each university compare.

Financial aid

NTU and HKUST each offer a range of financial aid options to help students fund their studies. For example, at NTU, loans, bursaries and scholarships are available, and the university has a calculator which students can use to determine their annual financial need. Scholarships offered by NTU include the Nanyang Scholarship for outstanding undergraduate students of any nationality, the Nanyang President's Graduate Scholarship, which seeks to encourage graduates to study a PhD at NTU, and the NTU Research Scholarship for prospective local or international PhD students.

Meanwhile, HKUST’s Scholarships and Financial Aid Office (SFAO) should be students’ main port of call in searching for financial assistance at the university, with a range of scholarships, bursaries and loans available. Students can use the university’s scholarship search tool to find scholarship options relating to their subject and study level, with 145 available at the time of writing. Students could also research their eligibility for a HKSAR Government Scholarship – 86 of these were awarded in the 2016/17 academic year. PhD students could apply for the Hong Kong PhD Fellowship Scheme (HKPFS).

Want more content like this? Register for free site membership to get regular updates and your own personal content feed.

This article was originally published in September 2014. It was last updated in June 2018 to incorporate the latest ranking results.